Shopping for the ideal mattress for your sleeping needs is a stressful experience. With so many brands to choose from, such as leading brands like Casper and Amerisleep, you may not know where to begin. Since your mattress is something you use every day, take time to find the right model. No one wants to miss out on a good night’s sleep. So don’t rush the shopping process. Otherwise, you may select a mattress that causes aches, pains, or difficulty in sleeping. To help you decide which of these two leading brands is better suited for your needs, we wrote this comparison by consulting Casper mattress reviews and Amerisleep reviews.
There are key similarities and differences to consider between the two companies. Check out this comprehensive guide highlighting the pros and cons of each.
By the time you finish reading, you will know exactly which one best suits your sleeping needs. This article will cover:
- Company Origins
Both companies sell their mattresses online and have a select amount of brick-and-mortar showrooms. Customers navigate their websites to find the right mattress, order online and have it shipped directly to their door. Both companies design and make their mattresses in the United States.
If you prefer to try out your bedding products in-person, both companies have locations throughout the United States. Customers can stop by, test out the beds, and have the mattress delivered to their home.
However, since these companies started out and still mainly sell online, their products are affordable and come with a free sleep trial.
Materials Used in Casper Mattresses and Amerisleep
Materials used in a mattress impact everything from the durability to comfort. If you prefer eco-friendly products, consider the environmental impact of the company and its products.
Both of these mattress companies work to reduce the number of chemicals in their materials. Casper is CertiPUR-US® certified, meaning the mattresses avoid harmful, ozone-depleting chemicals and emissions. Amerisleep is CertiPUR-US® certified as well, and it also uses partially plant-based materials. Additionally, Amerisleep is the only mattress company in the United States to use the Variable Pressure Foaming (VPF) process to produce its foam. VPF creates virtually zero emissions and allows Amerisleep to have more control over its product while helping the environment.
The Composition of Casper Mattresses vs. Amerisleep
Now that we have gone over the materials, next let’s review how it all comes together, to provide comfort and support.
First, Casper makes three mattresses, ranging from 8.5 inches tall to 11.5 inches tall. Those heights are on the average to shorter-than-average scale, meaning most Casper mattresses are likely to feel firm or medium-firm.
Second, none of their mattresses have memory foam as the top layer. Instead, they put poly-foam as the top layer. Poly-foam does not adapt or contour as memory foam does. Again, this will give Casper mattresses a firmer feel. Beneath the first layer of poly-foam, the Essential and the Casper mattresses have memory foam, designed to provide pressure relief. In the Wave, Casper’s most expensive mattress, beneath the first layer of poly-foam is a layer of latex foam, designed to give more support and bounce. Latex is a quality product but comes with its own pros and cons, to do more research on latex, read our post on latex and memory foam.
It’s important to remember the Casper and the Wave offer zoned support, while the Essential does not.
Amerisleep mattresses vary in composition depending on the model you select, as Amerisleep mattresses are designed with specific sleepers in mind.
First, each Amerisleep mattress has a Celliant® cover. Celliant® is FDA-determined1 to promote more restful sleep and faster recovery. Amerisleep’s Celliant® cover recycles your body heat into a beneficial infrared light, promoting a temporary increase in local blood flow, creating a rejuvenating and cool sleeping environment.
Second, each Amerisleep mattress has its plant-based memory foam as the top layer. It is uncommon to find a company that puts memory foam as the top layer, due to the concerns of memory foam sleeping hot. However, Amerisleep’s Bio-Pur® layer is a plant-based foam, making it five times more breathable than traditional memory foam. This helps reduce any concerns of sleeping hot and also makes Amerisleep a contender for the best memory foam mattress.
Third, four out of the five Amerisleep mattresses offer zoned support with their HIVE® layer. The HIVE® layer is not offered in the AS1, which helps make it Amerisleep’s firmest mattress.
Fourth, the AS5, Amerisleep’s softest and, at 14 inches, thickest mattress, has an extra layer of foam called Active Flex. Active Flex is a latex-like foam, directly beneath the top Bio-Pur® layer, creating a cloud-like feeling for a truly soft and supportive sleep.
The main difference between the two companies is the Amerisleep models form a family of mattresses designed for specific sleepers and specific needs. Casper does offer three mattresses, but they seemed catered towards types of budgets.
Casper Mattress Models vs. Amerisleep Mattress Models
One of the best ways to find the right mattress for you is by comparing the models offered. Sometimes the descriptions can be a little overwhelming, but the details are important to ensure a good fit. If you know what type of sleeper you are, it makes finding the right model a little easier.
Each of the three models has a different number of layers. Customers can select from:
- The Wave: The Wave features five foam layers to promote spinal alignment. At 11.5 inches tall, this is a relatively thin mattress for five layers, giving it a firmer feel.
- The Casper: The Casper comes with four foam layers and is 10 inches tall. Unlike the Wave, it does not contain a latex layer but provides zoned support and pressure relief using a combination of memory foam and poly-foam.
- The Essential: The Essential features three foam layers and is 8.5 inches tall, making it their shortest and firmest mattress.
Casper mattresses, given their height and firmness, may be better suited for stomach and back sleepers. If you tend to be a side sleeper, you may opt for a different brand as we discovered, in our search for the best mattress for side sleepers, that a good amount of cushion is preferred.
Amerisleep mattresses come in five, easy-to-understand models. The mattresses are simply named AS1-AS5, and the higher the number, the softer the mattress. The models are:
- Firm mattress (AS1)
- Medium-firm mattress (AS2)
- Medium mattress (AS3)
- Medium-soft mattress (AS4)
- Soft mattress (AS5)
The characteristics of firm, medium-firm, medium, medium-soft, and soft help customers easily select a mattress. For instance, stomach sleepers and back sleepers need a mattress that provides firmness (such as the AS1 or AS2). If you don’t stick to one position at night, you may want to choose the medium mattress for a blend of firm and softness (like the AS3). Side sleepers should choose the medium-soft to soft mattresses (this would mean the AS4 or AS5). These provide pressure relief for your hips and shoulders while you sleep.
Price Comparisons and Conclusion
For some, the price of the mattress may factor in heavily. It helps to plan ahead for this added expense in your budget. However, keep in mind a good night’s sleep is crucial to your health and well-being.
The three Casper prices vary from $600 to $1,995 for a Queen size. This means, from the 8.5-inch mattress to the 11.5-inch mattress, there is a $1,395 jump in price.
Amerisleep’s models range from $1,199 to $2,099 for a Queen size. This means, from their 10-inch AS1 to their 14-inch AS5, there is a $900 difference in price. As the mattresses get softer, the amount of foam increases, so the price increases.
Amerisleep’s pricing structure and design that caters to different types of sleepers give it a unique edge over its competitors. Also, Amerisleep’s technologically-advanced materials deliver the right mixture of comfort and support, promoting a great night’s sleep.
Finding the best mattress to fit your particular sleeping needs is critical to getting a good night’s sleep. Luckily, online companies like Amerisleep and Casper are making it easier. These online bed-in-a-box companies are more transparent, more affordable, and more customer friendly. They are very different companies, in terms of the type of mattresses they make and ship out, but hopefully, this comparison serves as a helpful guide while you make your choice.
1 The FDA has determined that Celliant® products are medical devices as defined in section 201(h) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act and are general wellness products. Celliant® is determined by the FDA to temporarily promote increased local blood flow at the site of application in healthy individuals. Hologenix, LLC, the maker of Celliant®, states that Celliant® safely converts body heat to infrared energy. This energy penetrates into the muscle and tissue to promote a temporary increase in local blood flow and helps increase comfort and promotes restful sleep.